Silicone is perhaps the best flexible material for sex toys, and it is an excellent option for butt plugs. It is because silicone is non-porous, body-safe, easy to clean, and semi-flexible; all of these features make it fantastic to use. Silicone butt plugs are also effortless to clean and maintain, as you can wash them with soap and water, a sex toy cleaner, and even clean them with boiling water. To help you make a good choice, we have tested a bunch of silicone butt plugs from our store inventory, and here we bring you a list of the best silicone butt plugs that will provide an unmatched experience.
Quick Overview of Our Top Picks
- Best Overall Choice: VeDO Bump Plus Rechargeable Remote Control Anal Vibe
- Best Value: Blush Temptasia Bling Silicone Plug
- Best for Beginners: Blush Luxe Beginner Plug
- Best Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug: Femme Funn Plua Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control
- Best Large Silicone Plug: Pretty Love Silicone Anal Plug with Weighted Balls
- Best Silicone Butt Plug Kit: Fantasy For Her – Her Little Gems Trainer Set
- Best Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug: Sensuelle Mini Beginner Butt Plug
- Best Wearable Silicone Butt Plug: Blush Luxe Slim Vibrating Butt Plug
- Best App-Controlled Silicone Butt Plug: Lovense Hush 2 Butt Plug
- Best Jeweled Silicone Butt Plug: Booty Bling Jeweled Butt Plug
- Best Tail Silicone Butt Plug: Tailz Fox Tail Butt Plug
- Best Weighted Silicone Butt Plug: b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 3
The Best Deals This Week*
- Femme Funn Plua Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control — $88.99 (List Price $121.99)
- Fantasy For Her - Her Little Gems Trainer Set — $41.99 (List Price $56.99)
- Lovense Hush 2 Butt Plug — $118.99 (List Price $132.99)
- Tailz Fox Tail Butt Plug — $36.99 (List Price $68.99)
- b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 3 — $56.99 (List Price $100.99)
*Deals are selected by our commerce team
Deep Dive: Our Top Picks VeDO Bump Plus Rechargeable Remote Control Anal VibeBest Overall Choice Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItThe VeDO Bump Plus Rechargeable Remote Control Anal Vibe is an incredible model, which is why we’ve placed it as the best overall choice for a silicone butt plug. First off, its design is slimline and optimized for easy insertion, and the base is T-shaped and broad, supporting safe use. The plug has a rounded tip for easy insertion, which is always a good thing in a quality butt plug. The compact VeDO Bump Plus Rechargeable Remote Control Anal Vibe also comes with vibrations; it comes with ten speed settings that you can control via the provided wireless remote controller. It is USB rechargeable for convenient use. Also, the VeDO Bump Plus Rechargeable Remote Control Anal Vibe is encased in body-safe, silky smooth silicone that is compatible with water-based lubes. It is also fully waterproof, so you can play with it in different environments. Who It's ForThe VeDO Bump Plus Rechargeable Remote Control Anal Vibe is perfect for everybody looking for a quality silicone butt plug with an optimized shape and size and excellent features. What Customers Are Saying - Love it! I’m using this toy every day! It feels really good! I’m using it only for anal play and is very comfortable. Love it! - Jennifer - Love it This is my first anal vibe and I completely love it! It is exactly what I was looking for. - Elias Reasons to Buy✓ Optimized shape and size ✓ Silky-smooth silicone ✓ Vibrations and wireless remote controller ✓ Waterproof and USB rechargeable Reasons to Avoid✗ The vibes may be powerful for some
Sold out | ||||||||
Blush Temptasia Bling Silicone PlugBest Value Silicone Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItThe Blush Temptasia Bling Silicone Plug is one of the silicone butt plugs we tested and caught our attention. It is very well designed and made from high-quality materials while still coming at a very affordable price point. The shape is very ergonomic and optimized for easy insertion. The body is wide for a good stretch, the neck is slim, and the base is heart-shaped for some extra excitement. The base also features a faux gem that adds some bling to your playtime. The plug is made from silicone with a silky-smooth finish that feels wonderful to the touch and is non-porous, body-safe and phthalate-free. The entire plug is lightweight and perfect for prolonged wear, and it is compatible with water-based lubes. You can also use it for temperature play and clean it with ease. Who It's ForThe Blush Temptasia Bling Silicone Plug is for all the users who are looking for a well-made butt plug made from silicone that is great to use. Reasons to Buy✓ Seamless silicone surface ✓ Ergonomic shape and size ✓ Heart-shaped base with jewel ✓ Waterproof use Reasons to Avoid✗ May be too small for pros
Sold out | ||||||||
Blush Luxe Beginner PlugBest for Beginners Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItThe Blush Luxe Beginner Plug is one of the best silicone butt plugs for beginners. The shape is optimized for easy insertion, with a tapered tip, a slightly broadened body, a narrow neck, and a broad base that allows safe use; it doubles as a suction cup base. It is made entirely from body-safe silicone that you can use with water-based lubes. We love this butt plug, as it is perfect for temperature play: you can heat it or cool it down and enjoy exciting sensations. The silicone surface is non-porous and silky smooth and is free from phthalates, paraffin, and latex. Washing it is easy, so you can rinse it with soap and water, sex toy cleaners, or wash it in the dishwasher. Who It's ForThe Blush Luxe Beginner Plug is perfect for beginners, as this model features a shape optimized for easy insertion and is made from platinum-cured silicone. Reasons to Buy✓ Platinum cured silicone ✓ Satin smooth surface ✓ Optimized shape ✓ Suction cup base Reasons to Avoid✗ Too thin for some users
Sold out | ||||||||
Femme Funn Plua Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote ControlBest Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItThe Femme Funn Plua Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control is one of the sexiest silicone butt plugs we’ve tested. It has a fun shape that is anatomically designed and feels exquisite when you insert it, as the tip is blunt and continues into a broad body. The neck is slim, and it continues into a T-shaped base that sits comfortably on the outside of the anus. Plua also vibrates, and you can scroll through ten vibration modes via the buttons on the base or the wireless remote controller. The plug is USB rechargeable and is fully waterproof. Its surface is coated with body-safe silicone that is waterproof and compatible with water-based lubes. Please note that you can easily wash it with soap and water and store it away from other silicone toys. Who It's ForThe Femme Funn Plua Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control is for everyone looking for a vibrating butt plug that is made from premium silicone and comes with a sexy shape. What Customers Are Saying - Amazing quality Amazing quality and addition to my already rich collection. Highly recommend, you won’t regret buying it one bit. - Nina - My wife and I love it Great for couples play. My wife and I love it. It’s let us live out some fantasies, like being together at the movies or a club and me discreetly using the remote. - W Reasons to Buy✓ Premium silicone surface ✓ Vibrating and USB rechargeable ✓ Wireless remote controller ✓ Waterproof use Reasons to Avoid✗ It may be small for some users
Sold out | ||||||||
Pretty Love Silicone Anal Plug with Weighted BallsBest Large Silicone Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItWe chose the Pretty Love Silicone Anal Plug with Weighted Balls as an excellent example of a large silicone butt plug. The model comes with a bulbous tip and broad body, so we recommend you get this model if you have previous experience with anal toys. The neck is relatively narrow, and the base is T-shaped for safe use. The trick with this plug is that it is weighted; the body of the plug has hollow chambers where small balls are inserted and can move freely, adding a subtle massage to your nether regions as you move with the plug. It is made from luxurious silicone that feels velvety to the touch and is hypoallergenic, non-porous, and body-safe. It is also waterproof and effortless to clean. Who It's ForThe Pretty Love Silicone Anal Plug with Weighted Balls is incredible, and we love it. We recommend it to experienced users that know how to make the most of this large silicone butt plug. Reasons to Buy✓ Seamless silicone ✓ Weighted balls inside ✓ T-shaped base ✓ Waterproof use Reasons to Avoid✗ Can be too big for some users
Sold out | ||||||||
Fantasy For Her - Her Little Gems Trainer SetBest Silicone Butt Plug Kit Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItWe chose the Fantasy For Her – Her Little Gems Trainer Set as this is an excellent silicone butt plug kit. It consists of three butt plugs in increasing sizes – a small, medium, and large plug, each in a different color. These feature a spade-like shape that is optimized for easy insertion and smooth use. But we also found these exciting to use, especially for beginners, as the smallest one is relatively easy to use and fits first-time users. The bases of the Fantasy For Her – Her Little Gems Trainer Set plugs all feature beautiful faux gems that add some sparkle to your fun. We also love that these are encased in seamless silicone that is non-porous, phthalate-free, latex-free, fragrance-free, waterproof, and compatible with water-based lubes. Who It's ForThe Fantasy For Her – Her Little Gems Trainer Set is ideally suited for beginners and gentle players looking for silicone butt plugs that are optimized for easy insertion. What Customers Are Saying - Slipped right in Once I got these I went right for the big one since I have experience. It slipped right in and settled against my opening very nicely. - Emmanuelle - Great for newbies Perfect for beginners, great price - Olivia Reasons to Buy✓ Set of three plugs ✓ Spade-like shape ✓ Jeweled base ✓ Body-safe silicone Reasons to Avoid✗ Not for experienced users
Sold out
| ||||||||||||||||
Blush Luxe Slim Vibrating Butt PlugBest Wearable Silicone Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItWe chose the Blush Luxe Slim Vibrating Butt Plug to go on our list, as we found it to be one of the most exciting butt plugs for prolonged wear. Its design is so good that it does not need any batteries or motors to provide some vibrations. Instead, the interior features an ingenious design: it has a hollow ball inside that has a smaller weighted ball that moves with the movements of the plug, so you get to feel gentle vibrations as you move with it. The outer shape is designed for prolonger wear in mind, as the blunt tip and wide body continue to a narrow neck that sits on the sphincter and an anchor base that is thin and does not rub on the butt but still provides safe use. The plug is made from body-safe, latex, and phthalate-free silicone that is waterproof and compatible with water-based lubes. Who It's ForThe Blush Luxe Slim Vibrating Butt Plug is for all the users who are looking for a silicone butt plug that is optimized for prolonger wear. The passive vibrations are an extra perk. What Customers Are Saying - No regrets Highly recommend. After an hour of wear I found it very comfortable and perhaps a little too pleasurable, had to remove as I could not think straight - Savannah - Powerful and intuitive Great butt plug. Easy insertion and very powerful vibrations. - Delilah Reasons to Buy✓ Designed for prolonger wear ✓ Passive vibrating ball ✓ Body-safe silicone ✓ Waterproof use Reasons to Avoid✗ Experienced users may find it lacking
Sold out | ||||||||
Lovense Hush 2 Butt PlugBest App-Controlled Silicone Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItWe added the Lovense Hush 2 Butt Plug to our list, as this model is genuinely incredible. The plug has an optimized tapered design that allows easy insertion and prolonged wear time because the base prevents it from traveling where it should not. Hush 2 is made from body-safe silicone that is smooth and velvety to the touch and is compatible with water-based lubes. We love that not only does it vibrate and is USB rechargeable, but it is also app-controlled, so you can use the Lovense app to experiment with vibrations and patterns. It is waterproof and easy to clean. Plus, the Lovense Hush 2 Butt Plug comes in four different sizes, so everyone, no matter your experience with anal toys, will probably enjoy this plug immensely. Who It's ForThe Lovense Hush 2 Butt Plug is for everyone looking for a high-quality silicone butt plug that has an optimized shape and comes with endless vibrating pattern options. What Customers Are Saying - Beautiful Such a beautiful butt plug that I love inserting in my wife’s beautiful butt. The price is high but quality sex toys are worth it! - Simon - AMAZing!!! This is my first vibrating butt plug and I’m amazed by the features and sensations. Next time I’ll get a larger size! - Max Reasons to Buy✓ Ergonomic tapered design ✓ App-controlled vibrations ✓ Body-safe silicone ✓ Waterproof use Reasons to Avoid✗ Expensive
Sold out | ||||||||
Booty Bling Jeweled Butt PlugBest Jeweled Silicone Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItA great way to spice up your anal play and provide some extra visual stimuli to your partner is to use a jeweled butt plug, which is why we added the Booty Bling Jeweled Butt Plug to our list. The butt plug has a spade-like shape that is optimized for easy use and has a long neck and a broad, round base. The base features a sparkly acrylic jewel that catches the light and sparkles, creating a more exciting atmosphere. The toy is made from body-safe, phthalate-free silicone that feels excellent to the touch. Another thing about this plug is that it is fully waterproof, so you can play with it wherever you want, and cleaning it is almost effortless. Who It's ForThe Booty Bling Jeweled Butt Plug is for people looking for a silicone butt plug that provides a good stretch and offers some more excitement with a jeweled base. What Customers Are Saying - Unbeatable price to quality ratio The quality is just as expected, and the price is unbeatable! Would recommend to everybody who is into a bit more interesting play. - Harry - Stays put Stays in place and enhances the sexual experience. - Dora Reasons to Buy✓ Body-safe silicone ✓ Acrylic jewel in the base ✓ Optimized spade shape ✓ Waterproof use Reasons to Avoid✗ No vibrations
Sold out
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Why Trust Our Reviews?
HotCherry’s editorial team includes sex experts, including sexologists, sexual health writers, product testers, and researchers. Having an editorial team lets us get a holistic view of the products in each category and choose the best products from top brands. We also have first-hand access to customer reviews on our website and consult with our customer service team to identify potential issues and defects of the products in our lists after long-term use.
Our selection method is meticulous: our experts hand-pick the best products to feature in each guide based on customer reviews, popularity, brand reputation, product features, and customer satisfaction post-purchase. Then, the editorial team personally tests and reviews every product, looking for all the traits that make a product unique and worthy of being featured in our best products lists. Then, we summarize the findings and bring detailed buying guides that are helpful for you.
When reviewing a product, our experts pay attention to the material, shape, size, and features with a keen eye and point out potential issues of every product. We also call out what the product feels like based on our reviewers’ personal experiences, which helps us bring you valuable insight.
See More Of Our Favorite Sex Toys
Best Glass Butt Plugs
Best Thrusting Dildos
Best Dual Density Dildos
Best Silicone Dildos
Best Squirting Dildos
Best Realistic Dildos
Best Cheap Dildos
Best Anal Dildos