Animal fetish is a common fantasy, and using a tail butt plug is a perfect way to explore a pet play fantasy. Using this toy allows you to provide a visual show for your partner and makes you feel more excited than usual. So, you need to choose a proper model that will fit your needs and experience level. So, here we’ll discuss all the best tail butt plugs we have in our store for you, and we’ll also touch upon the most important things to know about tail butt plugs. Even if you don’t have an animal fetish, you can try using tail butt plugs to spice up your sex life.
Quick Overview of Our Top Picks
- Best Overall Choice: Tailz Animal Tail Butt Plug
- Best Value: White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug
- Best for Beginners: Tailz Bunny Tail Butt Plug
- Best Vibrating Tail Butt Plug: Tailz Snap on Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug with Remote
- Best Extra Long Tail Butt Plug: Tailz Extra Long Mink Tail Butt Plug
- Best Glass Tail Butt Plug: Fluffer Bunny Tail Glass Anal Plug
- Best Metal Tail Butt Plug: Rainbow Foxy Rail Stainless Steel Butt Plug
- Best Multi-Feature Tail Butt Plug: Remote Control Wagging Bunny Tail Anal Play
The Best Deals This Week*
- Remote Control Wagging Bunny Tail Anal Plug — $83.99 (List Price $124.99)
- Tailz Animal Tail Butt Plug — $36.99 (List Price $54.99)
- Tailz Snap On Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug with Remote — $91.99 (List Price $123.99)
- Tailz Extra Long Mink Tail Butt Plug — $46.99 (List Price $72.99)
- Rainbow Foxy Tail Stainless Steel Butt Plug — $33.99 (List Price $50.99)
*Deals are selected by our commerce team
Deep Dive: Our Top Picks Tailz Animal Tail Butt PlugBest Overall Choise Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItThe Tailz Animal Tail Butt Plug is incredible in many ways, which is why we placed it as the best overall choice for a tail butt plug. The butt plug section of this toy is made from borosilicate glass which is one of the best body-safe materials for sex toys. It is smooth, non-porous, and compatible with all lube types. Also, glass quickly warms to a temperature you want, so you can use it to experiment with cold or warm sensations. The tail section is made from realistic-looking faux fur with a fox tail design. The tail is about 8 inches long, and you can use it to tease yourself, or you can put on a show performing as a sexy fox for your partner. The plug is waterproof and compatible with all lube types, but you need to be careful with the fox tail, as it is not intended to be used in water. Who It's ForThe Tailz Animal Tail Butt Plug is incredible, and we believe that everyone looking for a fun, sexy tail butt plug will find this model appealing and sexy to use. Reasons to Buy✓ Borosilicate glass butt plug ✓ Faux fur fox tail ✓ Compatible with all lubes ✓ Waterproof plug Reasons to Avoid✗ The tail is not waterproof
Sold out | ||||||||
White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal PlugBest Value Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItWe chose the White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug as we found it is one of the best-value models you can find. The butt plug has a spade shape with a blunt tip for easy insertion and has a long neck that sits comfortably on the sphincter. The base continues into an adorable white fluffy bunny tail that just looks amazing stuffed between the butt cheeks. The plug is made from metal, it is very shiny, and it is compatible with all lubes so that you can experiment and enjoy. We also love that the White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug is perfectly sized for beginners and gentle players, but it will also serve experienced users. You can heat it or cool it down for extra sensations, and it is waterproof for easy cleaning. Who It's ForThe White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug is for all anal play lovers looking for a quality tail butt plug that comes at a very affordable price. Reasons to Buy✓ Comfortable spade shape ✓ Shiny metal plug ✓ White fluffy bunny tail ✓ Compatible with all lubes Reasons to Avoid✗ It may be too slim for some
Sold out | ||||||||
Tailz Bunny Tail Butt PlugBest for Beginners Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItWhen testing different tail butt plugs, we came upon Tailz Bunny Tail Butt Plug, and we instantly loved how this looked and felt. The butt plug has a tapered shape with a blunt tip that is optimized for easy insertion and safe use. The plug is made from body-safe, velvety TPR that is somewhat flexible for more comfort when using it. Also, the plug is compatible with water-based lubes and is waterproof for easy cleaning. We love it also for the white fluffy bunny tail that is attached to the base of the plug, and when you insert it into your bum, you get transformed into a cute bunny for more erotic enjoyment. The tail is made from delicate feathers that feel exquisite when they touch your behind. Who It's ForThe Tailz Bunny Tail Butt Plug is for beginners who want to enjoy anal play and want a tail butt plug with non-threatening dimensions and a bunny tail. Reasons to Buy✓ Bunny tail from feathers ✓ Ergonomic shape ✓ Non-threatening size ✓ Semi-flexible Reasons to Avoid✗ Made from TPR
Sold out | ||||||||
Tailz Snap On Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug with RemoteBest Vibrating Tail Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItThe Tailz Snap on Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug with Remote is an entire kit with excellent features. The main butt plug has a very comfortable shape and size and is made from body-safe silicone that is compatible with all lubes. It has a tapered shape and an anchor-shaped base for safe use. The plug itself comes with powerful vibrations; it comes with three vibrating levels and seven patterns that you can control via the wireless remote controller. It is also USB rechargeable and easy to clean. We love this also because it comes with three tail attachments that you can interchange as the mood strikes. There is a pink fluffy bunny tail, a grey fox tail, and a white fox tail, and these have snap-ons that attach to the plug. Still, you can use the butt plug without the tails if you like, so you have plenty of options. Who It's ForThe Tailz Snap on Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug with Remote is for everyone looking for a vibrating anal plug that quickly transforms for different role-playing games. What Customers Are Saying - Good The anal plug is fun to use, and we love the vibrations and the remote control option. However, the tails are hard to snap them on and off. - JJ - Fun The butt plug is great and the battery life is surprisingly good, but the tails are difficult to snap on and off. - Leah Reasons to Buy✓ Silicone, tapered butt plug ✓ Vibrations and wireless remote ✓ Three interchangeable tail attachments ✓ Body-safe and easy to maintain Reasons to Avoid✗ The plug may be too small for some
Sold out | ||||||||
Tailz Extra Long Mink Tail Butt PlugBest Extra Long Tail Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItLooking for a more pronounced statement tail? Well, here we give you the Tailz Extra Long Mink Tail Butt Plug that has a very, very long mink tail. The tail is 30 inches long and made from very soft and fluffy faux fur, imitating a sexy mink. Perfect for cosplay or providing a very sexy show for your partner, the tail is easy to maintain. The butt plug is made from body-safe aluminum; it has a shape that is optimized for easy insertion and prolonged wear. Because the metal retains heat, you can heat it or cool it down and experience different sensations. We love that the aluminum is also non-porous and very easy to clean, and you can use it with all lube types. Who It's ForThe Tailz Extra Long Mink Tail Butt Plug is for all the anal play lovers who want a firm metal butt plug to play with and an extra-long fluffy tail. What Customers Are Saying - I’m pleasantly surprised Much better than I expected it to be. Being paranoid, I gave a few small tugs where the plug meets the tail when it first arrived. There was no budging or ripping. The size of the plug will take some getting used to, but overall, I'm very satisfied with my purchase. - Dora - We both love it Absolutely love it so does the boyfriend! Super soft and longer then I thought! The plug even had a cute bag that came over it. Good quality will definitely be purchasing more soon. - Bertha Reasons to Buy✓ Extra-long mink tail ✓ Aluminum butt plug ✓ Universal shape and size ✓ Suited for temperature play Reasons to Avoid✗ The metal plug can be heavy for some users
Sold out | ||||||||
Fluffer Bunny Tail Glass Anal PlugBest Glass Tail Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItWe could not pass the Fluffer Bunny Tail Glass Anal Plug, as this one combines a perfectly shaped glass butt plug topped with fluffy feathers for an impressive and very pleasurable playtime. The butt plug is made from body-safe, firm glass that is compatible with all lubes. The glass is durable, easy to clean, and temperature-sensitive, so you can explore temperature play. The tail is made from white feathers and is shaped like a round bunny tail, and we loved playing with it. When inserted, the plug sits comfortably inside, and the bunny tail teases the butt cheeks and visually arouses both partners. Who It's ForThe FLuffer Bunny Tail Glass Anal Plug is suitable for a broad range of users, but it is perfect for users looking for a tail butt plug that is firm and compatible for temperature play. Reasons to Buy✓ Glass butt plug ✓ Ergonomic shape and size ✓ Temperature play ✓ White feathers shaped like a bunny tail Reasons to Avoid✗ Feathers can be hard to clean
Sold out
| ||||||||||||||||||
Remote Control Wagging Bunny Tail Anal PlugBest Multi-Feature Tail Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItOur test team gave rave reviews of the Remote Control Wagging Bunny Tail Anal Play, which is why we had to include it in our list of the best tail butt plugs. The butt plug is made from premium silicone that is phthalate-free, body-safe and splashproof. It can vibrate and can also wag left and right, so you not only experience the vibes internally, but you can wag your butt and bunny tail and visually tease your partner. The Remote Control Wagging Bunny Tail Anal Play has a wireless remote controller that allows you to scroll through the 10 modes, or you can give it to your partner and have them tease you. The plug is USB rechargeable. The plug continues into a fluffy bunny tail that feels lovely against the skin. It is easy to clean and maintain, and you will love playing with it. Who It's ForThe Remote Control Wagging Bunny Tail Anal Play is for everyone looking for a fun and exciting multi-feature tail butt plug made from body-safe materials. Reasons to Buy✓ Silicone butt plug ✓ Manageable shape and size ✓ Vibrating and wagging features ✓ Pink fluffy bunny tail Reasons to Avoid✗ May be challenging for beginners
Sold out | ||||||||
Why Trust Our Reviews?
HotCherry’s editorial team includes sex experts, including sexologists, sexual health writers, product testers, and researchers. Having an editorial team lets us get a holistic view of the products in each category and choose the best products from top brands. We also have first-hand access to customer reviews on our website and consult with our customer service team to identify potential issues and defects of the products in our lists after long-term use.
Our selection method is meticulous: our experts hand-pick the best products to feature in each guide based on customer reviews, popularity, brand reputation, product features, and customer satisfaction post-purchase. Then, the editorial team personally tests and reviews every product, looking for all the traits that make a product unique and worthy of being featured in our best products lists. Then, we summarize the findings and bring detailed buying guides that are helpful for you.
When reviewing a product, our experts pay attention to the material, shape, size, and features with a keen eye and point out potential issues of every product. We also call out what the product feels like based on our reviewers’ personal experiences, which helps us bring you valuable insight.
See More Of Our Favorite Sex Toys
Best Glass Butt Plugs
Best Thrusting Dildos
Best Dual Density Dildos
Best Silicone Dildos
Best Squirting Dildos
Best Realistic Dildos
Best Cheap Dildos
Best Anal Dildos