Fan of anal play? If yes, then you have probably already used a regular butt plug and wish to broaden your horizons. In that case, this post is for you, as here we share our selection of the best large butt plugs you can find in our store. We tested a lot of models and looked at the key features like design, materials, and features, and we have brought you our top choices. Please note that we also share vital data on choosing an excellent large butt plug that will provide the sensations you are after, as we tried to create an all-encompassing list of impressively made large butt plugs.
Quick Overview of Our Top Picks
- Best Overall Choice: Pretty Love Anal Plug with Weighted Balls
- Best Value: Blush Anal Adventures XXL Plug
- Best for Beginners: Master Series Triple Cones Anal Plug Set
- Best Vibrating Large Butt Plug: Booty Sparks 7X Light Up Butt Plug
- Best Weighted Large Butt Plug: b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 4
- Best Silicone Large Butt Plug: Squeezable Medium Silicone Anal Plug
- Best Metal Large Butt Plug: njoy Pure Plug 2.0 XL
- Best Multi-Feature Large Butt Plug: A-Play Rimmer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug with Remote
The Best Deals This Week*
- Blush Anal Adventures XXL Plug — $17.99 (List Price $27.99)
- Master Series Triple Cones Anal Plug Set — $45.99 (List Price $61.99)
- b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 4 — $66.99 (List Price $116.99)
- Squeezable Medium Silicone Anal Plug — $28.99 (List Price $43.99)
- A-Play Rimmer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug with Remote — $110.99 (List Price $157.99)
*Deals are selected by our commerce team
Deep Dive: Our Top Picks Pretty Love Silicone Anal Plug with Weighted BallsBest Overall Choice Our Rating: 4.9/5 Why We Picked ItWe were very impressed by the Pretty Love Anal Plug with Weighted Balls. The plug has a fantastic design, with a bulbous tip and a wide body that is optimized for easy insertion, a narrow neck, and a broad T-shaped base that sits comfortably on the anus, preventing the plug from going in too deep. The plug is weighted, which may not seem like something special; however, when you insert it, you’ll feel the full effect of the ball moving inside the plug as you move your body. The entire toy is made from luxurious, velvet-touch silicone that is non-porous, body-safe, and compatible with water-based lubes. The Pretty Love Anal Plug is waterproof and simple to clean. Who It's ForThe Pretty Love Anal Plug with Weighted Balls is for everyone, but experienced users will find the largest model very pleasing to use, as it is designed to stretch anyone’s limits. Reasons to Buy✓ Ergonomic shape ✓ Weighted ball inside ✓ T-shaped base ✓ Waterproof and submersible Reasons to Avoid✗ Only use with water-based lubes
Sold out | ||||||||
Blush Anal Adventures XXL PlugBest Value Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItThe Blush Anal Adventures XXL Plug is one of the best-value large butt plugs we tested. It features an ergonomic design that is optimized for easy insertion, with a blunt tip and a large conical body. The body is quite broad, so it will provide enough stretch even for more demanding users. The plug ends with a broad base for safe use and comfortable handling. We love that the plug has a seamless design, as it is made from satin-smooth, phthalate-free, body-safe PVC that is compatible with all lubes. It is also fragrance-free, so you can use it with peace of mind. The surface is non-porous and simple to wash and sterilize, so you’ll always have a clean toy to play with. Who It's ForThe Blush Anal Adventures XXL Plug is a large model that is suitable for many users, and we believe that experienced users who are looking for an extra stretch will find it satisfying to use. What Customers Are Saying - Firm, awesome stretch... I've spent the better part of a year riding this thing and is easy to travel with. It's pretty firm and it gives an awesome stretch for anyone trying to challenge themselves. - Rachel - Took a while to conquer I thought I was a pro at this but... This one took a long time and a lot of lube to conquer. - Caleb Reasons to Buy✓ Optimized shape ✓ Wide body ✓ Waterproof use ✓ Body-safe and fragrance-free Reasons to Avoid✗ PVC material
Sold out | ||||||||
Master Series Triple Cones Anal Plug SetBest for Beginners Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItWe had to include the Master Series Triple Cones Anal Plug Set in our list of the best large butt plugs, as this set is lovely and very versatile. The set comes with three plugs in increasing sizes, but unlike an anal training kit where the plugs start with a small size, the plugs in this kit start big and only get bigger. The shape is very well made, with a blunt tip and a large conical body that continues to a narrow neck and ends up in a broad base that doubles as a suction cup. The Master Series Triple Cones Anal Plug Set is made from body-safe TPE blend in an elegant black finish that is fit for people looking to expand their anal stretching experience. The surface is smooth and somewhat flexible and is compatible with water-based lubes. Who It's ForThe Master Series Triple Cones Anal Plug Set is for people who have some anal play experience but are still beginners when it comes to using large butt plugs. What Customers Are Saying - Take your time and have fun Easy to clean! Comfortable for beginners. I would start with the smaller ones. Take your time with them and have fun. I personally love this product. - Linda - Big jump from second to third.. First one was too small. The second plug is a little bit bigger.. the third one is kind of a big jump. It looks a lot bigger than the one before it... - Charliexx Reasons to Buy✓ Three black butt plugs ✓ TPE material ✓ Conical shape ✓ Waterproof Use Reasons to Avoid✗ TPE is not everyone’s favored material
Sold out | ||||||||
Booty Sparks 7X Light Up Butt PlugBest Vibrating Large Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.7/5 Why We Picked ItThe Booty Sparks 7X Light Up Butt Plug is incredible, as it combines an ergonomic shape that is optimized for easy insertion and several other sexy features. The plug has a spade-like shape and is made from smooth silicone that is compatible with water-based lubes. It has 7 vibration modes that you can control via the provided wireless remote controller. On top of the great shape and vibrations, the Booty Sparks 7X Light Up Butt Plug also has a LED base. It means your booty will light up in five different colors, depending on your mood. We love that it is also USB rechargeable and waterproof, so cleanup is a breeze. Who It's ForThe Booty Sparks 7X Light Up Butt Plug is impressive, and we love the optimized shape, broad body, vibrations, and light-show options, and we think everyone will find it pleasing to use. Reasons to Buy✓ Tapered tip and spade-shape ✓ LED light base ✓ 7 vibration modes ✓ Body-safe silicone Reasons to Avoid✗ Can be noisy
Sold out | ||||||||
b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 4Best Weighted Large Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItThe b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 4 is incredible, and we had to include it in our list of the best large butt plugs. It is made from seamless silicone that feels velvety-smooth to the touch and is compatible with water-based lubes. Its torpedo-like shape is also optimized for easy insertion and for comfortable extended wear. Who It's ForThe b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 4 is for all anal play enthusiasts who enjoy prolonged wear and want to feel a delicious weight in their backdoor. What Customers Are Saying - Huge advance in butt plugs This is exactly as stated and so comfortable and sexy. A big advance in butt plugs. At first, I was not sure how the shape was going to help with insertion. It looked pretty intimidating. After wearing it a few times I can say I had nothing to be afraid of. - Janette - Natural, ergonomic design I think I'm hooked on this design now. It feels so natural, like it was engineered to actually be a part of your body. - Jane Reasons to Buy✓ Seamless body-safe silicone ✓ Weighted balls inside ✓ Torpedo shape ✓ Long-term wearing Reasons to Avoid✗ Only use with water-based lubes
Sold out | ||||||||
Squeezable Medium Silicone Anal PlugBest Silicone Large Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItThe Squeezable Medium Silicone Anal Plug is something special, and we couldn’t pass it over. It features a lovely design with a tapered tip and a broad spade shape that provides an excellent feeling of stretching. It has a broad base that prevents over-insertion, and it doubles as a suction cup. Made from seamless silicone, the plug is soft, flexible, and squeezable and is compatible with water-based lubricants. Who It's ForThe Squeezable Medium Silicone Anal Plug is for everyone looking for a large silicone butt plug they can use for anal stretching and temperature play. What Customers Are Saying - Combine it with a vibrator, pure heaven I love it. First time trying a butt plug. Combine it with a vibrator and it’s heavenly - Mary - Perfect size Not too big, not too small. Stays in place, does not slip. Very comfortable for extended wear. This is great for whatever the rear occasion is. First timers don’t be scared, but it may take a minute to work in. Fantastic! - Andrew Reasons to Buy✓ Seamless silicone construction ✓ Flexible, squeezable butt plug ✓ Waterproof use ✓ Temperature play Reasons to Avoid✗ It may be too soft for some
Sold out
| ||||||||||||||||||
A-Play Rimmer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug with RemoteBest Multi-Feature Large Butt Plug Our Rating: 4.8/5 Why We Picked ItThe A-Play Rimmer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug with Remote is an impressive butt plug that is packed with features, which is why we included it in our list. The butt plug is large and optimized for easy insertion, with a smooth tapered tip, a lengthy body, a narrow neck, and a broad base. Its shape is swollen near the top, which allows you to pinpoint the P-spot and enjoy incredible sensations. But the plug also comes with vibrations and a remote controller and has rotating beads in the neck that provide a rimming sensation. It is water-resistant, so no playing with it in water, but you can still wash it with ease. The surface is made from body-safe silicone that is compatible with water-based lubes. Who It's ForThe A-Play Rimmer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug with Remote is for everyone looking for a butt plug with good size and plenty of features for combined pleasure. Reasons to Buy✓ Body-safe silicone ✓ Vibrations and rotating beads ✓ USB rechargeable ✓ Wireless remote controller Reasons to Avoid✗ Not waterproof
Sold out | ||||||||
Why Trust Our Reviews?
HotCherry’s editorial team includes sex experts, including sexologists, sexual health writers, product testers, and researchers. Having an editorial team lets us get a holistic view of the products in each category and choose the best products from top brands. We also have first-hand access to customer reviews on our website and consult with our customer service team to identify potential issues and defects of the products in our lists after long-term use.
Our selection method is meticulous: our experts hand-pick the best products to feature in each guide based on customer reviews, popularity, brand reputation, product features, and customer satisfaction post-purchase. Then, the editorial team personally tests and reviews every product, looking for all the traits that make a product unique and worthy of being featured in our best products lists. Then, we summarize the findings and bring detailed buying guides that are helpful for you.
When reviewing a product, our experts pay attention to the material, shape, size, and features with a keen eye and point out potential issues of every product. We also call out what the product feels like based on our reviewers’ personal experiences, which helps us bring you valuable insight.
Shop Large Butt Plugs
See More Of Our Favorite Sex Toys
Best Glass Butt Plugs
Best Thrusting Dildos
Best Dual Density Dildos
Best Silicone Dildos
Best Squirting Dildos
Best Realistic Dildos
Best Cheap Dildos
Best Anal Dildos