Save Up to 70% Off on Top Brands!

Get extra 15% off with code: CHERRY

Free Shipping on Orders $59+

10 Best Large Butt Plugs Reviewed

10 Best Large Butt Plugs Reviewed

Editorial Team |

Choosing a high quality large butt plug is very, very important. The design needs to be ergonomic and well thought out, giving you enough stretch without being uncomfortable.

To make the task of choosing easier for you, we have gone through dozens of products. Comparing those side by side and exploring the reputation of manufacturers, we choose the 10 best large butt plugs you can buy today.

The review is further completed through testimonial analysis. We’ve included the biggest pros and cons people listed for each item so that you have a highly realistic idea about what to expect.

Table of content

Our Top 10 Large Butt Plugs

10 Best Large Butt Plugs

Superb 9.8

#1 B-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug 4

Here’s a large butt plug that looks so very different from everything else you’ll find on the market. At the same time, the design isn’t random. It’s been chosen to optimize your pleasure and hit every single nerve during anal penetration. The B-Vibe Snug Plug 4 is crafted from silky smooth silicone that has been weighted for a more powerful sensation. The ergonomic design allows for effortless insertion, regardless of the plug’s size. There’s also a fairly narrow stem, increasing retention and making the plug comfortable to wear for prolonged periods of time. The stem and the anchor are both quite flexible, meaning you wouldn’t feel any sort of the discomfort when the plug is snuggly in place. This item is provided with an individual travel and storage bag for more hygienic and discreet toy keeping.


  • Weighted design adds a whole new dimension to anal play
  • The shape provides stimulation each time you move
  • Comfortable to wear longer, regardless of size
  • Well made, seamless design


  • Some users disliked the curves of the base
  • May hold some odor
  • Soaks up lube fairly quickly

Superb 9.7

#2 Je Joue Large Vibrating Butt Plug

Here’s another example of untraditional butt plug design that isn’t random. This particular shape has been provided to ensure unisex internal stimulation. Guys will definitely feel the targeted prostate massage. Ladies will benefit from some G-spot stimulation when the butt plug is inserted. The toy has the capacity of vibrating (the motor is sold separately, otherwise the toy can be used as a static plug). When the motor is attached, the plug becomes capable of delivering two varieties and three speeds of pleasurable vibrations. Made of high quality, non-porous silicone, the item is completely waterproof and bodysafe. And while the head is pronounced to ensure that much-craved stretch, the stem is fairly narrow and comfortable. A wide base provides the final safety feature.


  • Fun design for internal P-spot and G-spot stimulation
  • Super smooth silicone
  • Very easy to clean
  • Well-made and solid


  • A bit expensive
  • If you want vibrations, you have to buy motor separately

Superb 9.5

#3 Blush Luxe Candy Rimmer Plug

While this anal plug looks super cute, you shouldn’t be fooled by its appearance. It’s a fairly big butt plug that will give you an exceptional stretch and warrant brand new anal sensations. The Blush Luxe Candy Rimmer is available in three pretty colors. Its shape makes it look like a piece of jewelry but the design ensures an amazing stretch and targeted internal stimulation. A tapered tip guarantees easy insertion and there’s also a ring base for better gripping and manipulation. The item is made from waterproof, bodysafe silicone. While the material gives a bit of flexibility, it is stiff enough to ensure a stretch everyone will get to feel. On top of that, the item is designed with a bit of internal weight for a more intense sensation each time.


  • Well-made, seamless design
  • Very easy to insert
  • Super smooth silicone
  • Excellent price to quality ratio


  • Base is flexible, not good for hands-free use
  • A bit narrower than other large butt plugs

Superb 9.3

#4 Colt Large Inflatable Dilator

An inflatable butt plug takes the stretch to a whole new level. If you enjoy anal play, you should definitely try out one such item. The Colt large butt plug isn’t for the faint of heart. Its dimensions are big enough to make the plug satisfying on its own. At the same time, the plug can be inflated via a manual pump for a sensation like no other. A long hose makes the plug easy to use. There’s also a quick release valve for maximum safety and comfort. On top of these features, the dilator has a tapered tip for effortless insertion and a sufficiently flared safety base. A suction cup is also housed in the base, enabling hands-free fun. Made of super smooth silicone, the inflatable dilator is bodysafe and completely waterproof. It is very easy to sanitize, ensuring a safe and hygienic experience every single time.


  • Feels good, easy to insert
  • Very easy to inflate and deflate
  • Generously sized
  • Effortless sanitization


  • On the stiffer side
  • Some problems with pumping (after prolonged use)
  • Hose connection is somewhat fragile

Superb 9.0

#5 Blush Anal Adventures XL Plug

Blush Anal Adventures XL is a classic big plug. If you’re looking for a traditionally-shaped big anal toy, that one would be it. The plug has also the features needed to make it both comfortable and great to use. A soft, tapered tip allows for easy insertion. At the same time, the wide base is girthy enough to stretch the rectal walls deliciously. While the stem isn’t the narrowest one, it still feels comfortable when the toy is inside. Finally, the plug ends in a flared enough base to maximize safety during use. The base is equipped with a strong suction cup for hands-free use. This Blush butt plug is crafted from silky smooth, completely waterproof PVC. This material is very easy to clean and at the same time, it gives you total body safety and hypoallergenic properties.


  • Classic shape, very satisfying
  • Super smooth silicone
  • Suction cup works really well
  • Very easy to clean


  • Not the biggest toy out there
  • Made of PVC rather than silicone

Fabulous 8.8

#6 Triple Spades 3 Piece Anal Plug Set

Anyone who isn’t confident about the right butt plug size should consider getting a kit. The Triple Spades anal plug set is great for beginners, as well as for more advanced users. You will get three spade-shaped butt plugs that progressively grow bigger. You’ll get lengths varying from 2.6 to 3.8 inches and diameters in the range from 1.38 to two inches. Anchor-like bases ensure the easy and safe use of the plugs. They also have very narrow tips for easy insertion regardless of experience level. Made from super smooth TPR, the plugs are sturdy but still having a bit of flexibility. The material is bodysafe and waterproof. It is easy to sanitize and perfect for shower use. An added perk is the compatibility with all kinds of lube.


  • Three very reasonably priced plugs
  • Offer sufficient stretch
  • Feel super smooth and comfortable
  • Easy to clean


  • Not the biggest plugs out there
  • Not crafted from silicone

Fabulous 8.7

#7 Blush Anal Adventures XXL Plug

With its six inches of total length and width of three inches, this Blush Anal Adventures butt plug is perfect if you need some extra-stretch. While big enough, the plug is ergonomically designed to feel good and hit all of the right spots. There’s a tapered tip for very easy penetration. The plug offers gradual stretching and the neck is narrow enough to maximize retention. A wide base makes the plug completely safe to use. It also features a study suction cup for a bit of hands-free fun. Just like other plugs in the same range, this one is crafted from bodysafe PVC. The material is completely waterproof and it is very easy to clean. While PVC provides a bit of flexibility, the material is also stiff to maintain the stretch throughout the use.


  • Good size, good stretch
  • Excellent price to quality ratio
  • Easy to insert, even if you’re inexperienced
  • Very easy to sanitize


  • Quite big, beware of the size
  • Made of PVC and not of silicone

Fabulous 8.6

#8 Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug

Some people look for a more intense stretch from their anal toys. A wider stem is one of the design features that can ensure such a sensation. The Zero Tolerance Titan plug is a great choice for more experienced anal players. It measures 9.25 inches in length and 3.5 inches in width. Don’t be alarmed by the size – a tapered tip allows for effortless insertion. The stretch is gradual and gentle, sustained throughout the penetrative experience. A wide base makes the Zero Tolerance plug incredibly safe. The base also features a strong suction cup for fun hands-free use. Crafted from PVC, the plug is super smooth and bodysafe. The material is also completely waterproof – use the toy in the shower or submerge it in a cleaning solution for thorough sanitization.


  • Easy to insert
  • Perfect for intermediate and advanced players
  • Ensures optimal stretch
  • Very easy to clean


  • Quite expensive
  • Made of PVC and not silicone
  • Thicker stem not great for long-term retention

Fabulous 8.5

#9 Master Series Triple Cones Anal Plug Set

Graduated, spade-shaped anal plugs give you amazing opportunities for some anal training. And if you can’t decide on the right size, you should definitely seek out a kit. This Master Series set of three butt plugs is very versatile and ideal for both beginners and more experienced players. You will get three plugs ranging in length from 3.5 to 5.8 inches and in diameter from 1.7 to 2.9 inches. Each one is characterized by a tapered tip for very easy insertion. Even if you’ve never used an anal toy before, you’ll have an easy time with these ones. A flared base makes the plugs completely safe to use, regardless of how heated things get. The one distinctive characteristic here is a wider stem for consistent stretch throughout the use of the plugs. The toys in the set are crafted from bodysafe and waterproof TPE. This material is super smooth, hypoallergenic and also easy to maintain in flawless hygienic condition.


  • Three toys in one kit, excellent price
  • Easy to use
  • Feel very good, super smooth
  • Very easy to clean


  • Expensive for toys that aren’t crafted from silicone
  • On the smaller side

Fabulous 8.2

#10 Squeezable Medium Silicone Anal Plug

The classic spade shape makes this large plug versatile and easy to use. At the same time, the bigger size gives you the kind of stretch you wouldn’t get from a smaller anal toy. Squeezable and flexible, the plug has a tapered plug for fairly easy insertion. Going down, the toy gets progressively bigger to ensure such an amazing anal stretching experience. The stem is narrow for easy retention of the plug over a longer time period. At the same time, it will stretch the sphincter gently to make the enjoyable sensations consistent. A flared base is a much-needed safety feature. The base also has a built-in suction cup for some hands-free fun. Crafted from super-smooth silicone, the toy feels like silk. It is also hypoallergenic, bodysafe and 100 percent waterproof. You can sanitize the plug effortlessly after each use to give yourself both fun and safety.


  • Classic shape, very versatile
  • Very easy to insert, regardless of experience level
  • Super smooth silicone
  • A toy that’s effortless to clean


  • Not the biggest large plug out there
  • Some users dislike the squeezable nature of the item

Things You Should Pay Attention to When Shopping for a Large Butt Plug

Large butt plugs are created to give you extra stretch. Unlike their smaller counterparts, they aren’t meant for prolonged use. This is why a large butt plug can give you very intense sensations and even more powerful orgasms than smaller toys.

Because of these product specifics, you have to be careful about choosing the right design and product specs. Here are some of the most important things to look at when shopping for a large butt plug:

Size: What exactly is a large butt plug? That’s the first thing you need to define for yourself. What seems enormous to some people may be regular size for someone else. So, the selection is really up to personal preferences. If you’ve only used a butt plug that’s three-inches-long, a five-inch butt plug would be big for you. Grow the size gradually and increments. This way, you’ll build a collection of plugs that will give you a ton of versatility.

Shape: Because this butt plug is bigger than regular ones, the shape is even more important. The classic teardrop shape is still a good choice when you go for a bigger butt plug. Some people, however, prefer narrower shapes and sizes. A plug that’s a bit more angular will ensure more pronounced sensations. Such a shape, however, will require some getting used to. There are also some larger butt plugs that may be slightly curved or angled to achieve prostate stimulation. If you have a prostate and would like to enjoy an orgasm-inducing massage, get this kind of toy.

Material: A large butt plug should be made of a material that you feel comfortable with. Most people will enjoy a larger plug that’s somewhat stretchable and bendable. If you haven’t used a glass or metal butt plug before, don’t jump on a large one made of such materials. Try a smaller item first to find out if you enjoy the sensation. Medical-grade silicone is one of the best choices when it comes to big butt plugs. It’s smooth, it’s somewhat flexible and very long-lived. Not only will the material feel very nice, it will also ensure an optimal return on investment.

Look for flexibility: If you’re not confident about the specifics of your needs, you can still find a big butt plug that’s perfect. Choosing a kit is one option. Kits usually feature three or more progressively bigger plugs. They’re a great choice for anal training. Also, a kit is more affordable than buying items individually. Another item you may want to consider if you’re looking for flexibility is an inflatable butt plug. With an inflatable plug, you’re in control of the size and the stretch. The toy comes with a pump that gets air inside of it and allows the plug to grow. Experimenting with inflatable butt plugs can result in some seriously intense sensations you wouldn’t get from another item. If you go for an inflatable plug, do follow manufacturer guidelines for use because over-inflation can be somewhat dangerous.

Safety features: Safety should always be a priority when shopping for anal toys. The most important feature of all butt plugs, regardless of size, is the flared base. A flared base keeps the plug from getting sucked up inside the rectum and colon. If this happens, the plug can travel up very fast, which will call for a visit to the ER.

Additional pleasure features: Some of the larger butt plugs are weighted for added stimulation. This means they’re heavier (through the addition of some kind of core). As such, the toys will provide intense sensations you’ll get to feel during anal training or sex. Alternatively, you can seek vibrating large plugs. Combining the fullness and the pulsations will drive you mad and give you some of the most powerful orgasms ever. Finally, you may want to look for a plug that has a suction cup base. Such a toy can be used hands-free, giving you a chance to experiment with various positions while pleasuring yourself in alternative ways.

Ease of cleaning and use: Finally, make sure your large butt plug is easy to use, easy to clean and store. Check what kinds of lube the item is compatible with (since it’s a large butt plug, you’ll definitely need a lot of lube). Also, make sure that the plug is waterproof and non-porous. These characteristics will make it easy to clean and reduce the risk of the plug harboring bacteria even after it gets washed.

Why Should You Buy a Good Large Butt Plugs

Just doing a bit of online research will show you that the large butt plug market is huge (literally). You’ll find cheap toys, you’ll find premium toys and some more specialized choices. Do you need to pay that much attention to quality or should you just get the item that you like?

Quality should always be a main priority when you’re looking for sex toys. When it comes to larger items, it’s even more important.

Big butt plugs need to have the right design and seamless construction. Otherwise, they can become painful and even dangerous to use.

Reputable sex toy makers invest a lot in product design and development. Their items get tested and they also seek out the best materials to ensure a safe and pleasurable experience. In the absence of such steps, a large butt plug would be useless at best.

The sex toy industry is poorly regulated. There are very few requirements and almost no quality standards that sex toy makers have to adhere to. This is why you can easily come across poorly made products, products that fall apart after a few uses and items that have such a bad design you give up on them in a couple of tries.

A big butt plug should have a perfectly smooth, ergonomic construction. Any molding imperfection will make it difficult to use. In some instances, such toys could even cause minor injuries or even tears. Thus, you can’t just buy a big plug just because it costs 10 dollars. Trying to save a couple of bucks will eventually give you an item you cannot use or an item that falls apart almost immediately.

Always think about safety when looking for sex toys. It’s even more important when it comes to anal toys. A properly tapered tip, a manageable size and a flared base are all important. You cannot make a compromise with these characteristics.

The same applies to the materials that anal toys are made of.

Large butt plugs should be semi-flexible and very smooth. Some people like completely rigid options like glass and metal. These, however, aren’t everyone’s cup of tea. You may want to start out with silicone and eventually transition to something a bit more unorthodox.

Material is also linked to convenience and safety.

At the very least, a poorly chosen material will absorb odors, making the large butt plug unpleasant to use. In worse case scenarios, a material can also create perfect conditions for the proliferation of bacteria. If this ever happens, you risk getting a nasty infection each time you decide to enjoy your anal toy.

Don’t underestimate the importance of design and material selection when buying large butt plugs. These are usually costlier than smaller anal toys. When investing in such items, make sure that the quality is good enough to give you several years of use (at least). Finding the right item if you don’t have a lot of experience can be a bit of a gamble. This is why product rankings like the one we’ve just presented can come in handy.

Final Words

Once you conquer the regular sized butt plug, you can move on to something bigger, more challenging and much more satisfying.

A large butt plug is an item that fans of anal play adore. It can contribute to such heightened orgasms that you’ll never go back to a regular-sized toy. Ok, that’s a bit of an over-exaggeration but you get the picture.

For a large butt plug to give you pleasure, it needs a good shape, a good weight and a smooth material that will go in easily. You’ll find all three of these characteristics in the large plugs included in our top 10 list.

Also, understand the fact that large butt plug is a fairly generic term. The market features so many sub-divisions of products – classic plugs, inflatable plugs, vibrating toys or items especially designed for prostate stimulation. You don’t have to go for a classic large plug if that’s not your thing. Even if specialized items are rarer, they’re still fairly easy to find.

So, take a bit of time to decide exactly what you want. The experience you’re looking for will narrow down the options and help you choose the large butt plug that’s just right for you. And if you’re not 100 percent confident about the nature of the selection, you can always go for a kit that will guarantee diversity and versatility in its use.

Previous Next