How Does a Butt Plug Feel?

by Kate Miller on Dec 21 2025

Let’s be frank: anal sex can be pretty pleasurable if done correctly. When we say correctly, we mean doing proper preparation, plenty of lube (and we can’t stress the importance of using a fair amount of lube), good hygiene, relaxation, and going slowly. Let’s expand on this a bit more and cover the basics of how a butt plug feels.

Three pink butt plugs

Butt Plug Play Basics

When it comes to how does a butt plug feel, it is generally described as a feeling of fullness and more profound sensation due to a more thorough stimulation. Some people have said that using a butt plug will initially feel strange. However, after a few minutes, once the body accommodates the intrusion of the butt plug, the sensation turns pleasurable, and the overall experience gets enhanced.

If you are a complete novice at anal play, then it is best to prepare mentally, relax, and have enough foreplay before trying any type of booty fun. The sphincter area is full of nerve endings that get stimulated with anal play, which in turn heightens sensation and contributes to stronger orgasms.

When men use butt plugs or any other anal toy like a prostate massager, they feel the pleasure from the stimulation on their prostate or P-Spot. It leads to harder erections, prolonged orgasms, and deeper sensations.

It is relatively similar for the ladies, as the jeweled butt plug expands the anus and stimulates the A-spot that is located on the back wall of the vagina. It leads to enhanced vaginal intercourse; the body gets into a state of constant stimulation and more profound pleasure.

Tips for Comfortable Anal Play

Here are some tips that we found helpful when preparing and starting anal play. We must be clear that these are general tips that we’ve found helpful, and you should heed them as guidelines when using a butt plug:

  • Relax and breathe deeply – the first step is to relax and breathe deeply and have some foreplay. Once relaxed and in the mood, your rectal muscles relax, which makes insertion easier;
  • Use a clean butt plug – always make sure you wash the butt plug thoroughly before and after you play. Taking care of your health is essential, and you should never take any risks by playing with unclean toys;
  • Use plenty of lube – the anus is not a self-lubricating area, so using a good amount of lube is essential for comfortable and safe play. Avoid using numbing lubes, as they can mask any possible hurt. Always lube up the butt plug and the anus, and use a lube that works with the material of your butt plug;
  • Start with a beginner-friendly butt plug – we suggest you start with a beginner-friendly butt plug if you are a novice at anal play. Some excellent anal training kits have differently-sized butt plugs you can use to get introduced to the wonders of anal play;
  • Go slow and listen to your body – always go slow and listen to your body’s response. To insert the butt plug, press the tip of the butt plug against the anus and slowly increase the pressure; it should not be painful, but you will feel pressure. Once the butt plug is fully inside, leave it there as you continue sexual play.

Shop Lubes

7f32015f3d87bc67f64114ce0e148a97.jpg
526dfb90f4ac4a5ce458b0b8f5802b5a.jpg

Elbow Grease Original Cream Lubricant 9 oz

$26.40 $30.25 Save 13%
98c181eac5fa75fda4237e6e4ad9145d.jpg
3fa66abcde6f8d2c4f4c5207e322ebf7.jpg

Boy Butter H2O Lubricant Tub 4 oz

$20.95

$17.81 in cart, save 15%
f43a957ec899548a0f7e016e47ca2d40.jpg
743c75e4389e21d056ecc752aba18ae5.jpg
56a98d28b0452a1615d2827253e7b118.jpg
de1a213dcace197f1968292248c32aed.jpg

Swiss Navy Yummy Cummy Gummies 60 ct

$34.52 $36.99 $29.34 in cart, save 21%
33219b5b4b2f8f3fa41a63f13d3a13e4.jpg
b651d9a93afb3167882e828bc8809159.jpg
84d3195b4b233839dcff82e7bb57601d.jpg

Cock Oil Water Based Lubricant 10 oz

$29.95

View All Lubes

We hope our guide to how a butt plug feels and our tips on using a butt plug are helpful for you. Plus, we have a lot more helpful guides for using various sex toys, and we also have an excellent sex toy store that offers a broad range of exciting sex toys for everyone.

Shop All Anal Toys

Shop Anal Sex Toys

0f64ab4041b2ab603bba9843481955aa.jpg
11a846c296d38afee5eab3eba118d558.jpg
SE-0382-15-3_10__86444.1786136584704.jpg
SE-0382-15-3_11__71801.1786136584794.jpg

Lavender Haze Beaded Anal Probe

$39.95 $47.99 Save 17%
6b880b9c91dd95723092efb9e482cd61.jpg
deae9ed95c7ad9f9396844786cd25325.jpg
0cc6940ab88bda4f70e4209b61554df9.jpg
6590acccbea22b0e9a968c6eff146edd.jpg

Anal Fantasy Elite Twist Ecstasy in Black

$99.99

$84.99 in cart, save 15%
18aebeb2866ed05430aeb6994bee8996.jpg
53492f51ce0f4e5fbf47ea5dd9b8c9d1.jpg
7ad476bddada9ff36f33352e7fe9438d.jpg
07b1d44e32d14cf402c98b008c33d875.jpg

Bougie Plug – Remote-Controlled Vibrating Butt Plug

$117.49 $149.99 $99.87 in cart, save 33%
322284_1_4efbe010-331e-4a51-9e7f-3f48e0cbe056_1800x1800.1785447294299.webp
616b0f7d3d685791f9501f0a9699265f.jpg
213cc194b1909e7490dcd0b6bea2efae.jpg
e60a98daa0ac5df68dd7a84ed2a6b6fc.jpg

Bendz Plug Large in Black

$74.95 $95.00 Save 21%
View All Anal Sex Toys

Learn More With Our Anal Sex Toy Guides:

How To Use a Butt Plug
How To Use Anal Toys
How To Use Anal Trainers
How To Properly Stretch Your Anus
How To Use an Inflatable Butt Plug
How To Use A Prostate Massager
How To Anal Douche
How To Use Aneros Prostate Massagers