How to Choose Anal Toys?

by Kate Miller on Dec 18 2025

Anal play is not something new, but today we have an abundance of anal toys with advanced features that are so pleasurable to use. Here, our experts provide a detailed guide to anal toys, covering all you need to know about anal toys and what specific toys you can use to achieve anal stimulation. We will also discuss different anal sex toy varieties and materials, and we’ll share expert-supported tips on how to use the different anal toys for heightened pleasure.

What Are Anal Sex Toys?

Anal sex toys are a group of adult toys designed to be used for anal play. These include butt plugs, anal beads, prostate massagers, anal dildos, and other exciting toys that you can use in your backdoor. Each of these comes in simple and sophisticated variants, with models having very advanced features that provide highly satisfying sensations.

Shop All Anal Sex Toys

Shop Anal Sex Toys

Rear Assets Aluminum Plug with Gem
Rear Assets Aluminum Plug with Gem

Rear Assets Aluminum Plug with Gem

(7)

$14.95 From $9.00
Extra 10% off applied
Color
Colt 5 Inch Power Male Anal Vibrator
Colt 5 Inch Power Male Anal Vibrator

Colt 5 Inch Power Male Anal Vibrator

(0)

$36.95 $22.00
Extra 10% off applied
Booty Bling Silicone Anal Beads
Booty Bling Silicone Anal Beads

Booty Bling Silicone Anal Beads

(6)

$34.95 From $20.00
Extra 10% off applied
Color
Amethyst Rain Glass Anal Butt Plug
Amethyst Rain Glass Anal Butt Plug

Amethyst Rain Glass Anal Butt Plug

(9)

$28.95 $17.00
Extra 10% off applied
View All Anal Sex Toys

How to Choose Anal Sex Toys?

Choosing anal sex toys is straightforward if you know what you want and need. Before making a choice, consider the intended use, your experience level, and the expected sensations. Please note that the more honest you are in answering these questions, the better choice you will make when selecting an anal toy for you or your partner. Always select an anal toy made from body-safe materials that are compatible with your experience level, and make sure you get compatible lube.

  • Beginners should stick to beginner-friendly toys like anal trainers or small butt plugs that are easier and more comfortable to use. Don’t rush for a larger size toy right from the start, but enjoy and savor smaller toys to get your body accustomed to the sensations.
  • Intermediate users can try bigger toys and experiment with large butt plugs, anal dildos, and prostate massagers, as well as with vibrating plugs, as they already know what to expect and how they will react to the sensations.
  • Experienced users can go beyond with anal toys and try large butt plugs, weighted butt plugs, inflatable butt plugs, anal stretchers, and hollow butt plugs that provide more sensations.

Anal Sex Toy Materials

There are sex toys made from a wide variety of materials, but when it comes to anal sex toys, we prefer and advise you to pick body-safe materials that are comfortable to use and easy to clean and keep sterile. But it is expected to find anal sex toys made from:

  • Silicone – the best material for anal sex toys because silicone is hypoallergenic, flexible, odorless, non-porous, and body-safe. It is easy to wash and keep clean, and non-motorized silicone toys can be boiled or washed in a dishwasher to ensure proper cleaning and sterilization. Please note that silicone anal toys are only compatible with water-based lubes.
  • Glass – often used for sex toy manufacturing, glass is hypoallergenic, body-safe, odorless, non-flexible, and non-porous. Glass anal toys are a popular choice, as these are compatible with all lube types and are effortless to clean and sterilize.
  • Metal – stainless steel and aluminum are top choices for sex toy manufacturing, as these are hypoallergenic, body-safe, non-flexible, and non-porous. Metal sex toys are firm and deliver targeted sensations, which you can’t achieve with other materials other than glass. Metal anal toys are a popular choice because they are effortless to wash and sterilize, and these work with all lube types.
  • TPE/TPR – these are thermoplastic elastomer blends that are used for producing lifelike sex toys. While they look and feel like the real thing, TPE/TPR sex toys are porous and are challenging to clean, which is why we advise you to stay away from TPE/TPR anal toys. If you do get one of these, you can safely use it with a condom on to prevent contamination and facilitate cleaning.

Types of Anal Toys

As we noted, anal toys come in a great variety, which we believe you will find pleasurable to use. Here we share an overview of all the types of anal toys you can find in our sex toy store:

Anal Beads

Anal beads are a series of balls or beads that are strung in line on a cord and usually have increasing sizes, from small to large. One end has a loop by which you pull on the beads to pull them out of the anus, which provides varying stimulations on the muscles. The primary purpose of anal beads is to draw them out of the anus during an orgasm, which heightens the sensations and amplifies the orgasm.

Shop Anal Beads

Shop Anal Beads

Booty Bling Silicone Anal Beads
Booty Bling Silicone Anal Beads

Booty Bling Silicone Anal Beads

(6)

$34.95 From $20.00
Extra 10% off applied
Color
Satisfyer 3 Piece Anal Plug Set
Satisfyer 3 Piece Anal Plug Set

Satisfyer 3 Piece Anal Plug Set

(0)

$34.95 From $29.95
Color
Satisfyer Love Silicone Beads
Satisfyer Love Silicone Beads

Satisfyer Love Silicone Beads

(6)

$34.95 From $31.00
Color
Silicone Booty Beads
Silicone Booty Beads

Silicone Booty Beads

(6)

$19.95 $15.00
Extra 10% off applied
Color
View All Anal Beads

Butt Plugs

The butt plug has a conical shape, with a tapered tip, wide body, a slim neck and a flared base. The body of the plug is inserted in the anus, with the neck sitting on the anal sphincter, and the flared base sits on the outside, preventing the plug from getting lost up there.

Shop Butt Plugs

Shop Butt Plugs

Amethyst Rain Glass Anal Butt Plug
Amethyst Rain Glass Anal Butt Plug

Amethyst Rain Glass Anal Butt Plug

(9)

$28.95 $17.00
Extra 10% off applied
Satisfyer 3 Piece Anal Plug Set
Satisfyer 3 Piece Anal Plug Set

Satisfyer 3 Piece Anal Plug Set

(0)

$34.95 From $29.95
Color
Blush Luxe Beginner Plug
Blush Luxe Beginner Plug

Blush Luxe Beginner Plug

(0)

$12.95 From $8.80
Extra 10% off applied
Color
Medium Silicone Inflatable Plug
Medium Silicone Inflatable Plug

Medium Silicone Inflatable Plug

(0)

$59.95 $36.00
Extra 10% off applied
View All Butt Plugs

Prostate Massagers

The prostate massagers are specific anal toys that are designed for prostate owners, as these toys feature specific shapes that reach and stimulate the prostate. You can get a manual or a vibrating prostate massager and use it to stimulate the prostate for sexual pleasure or health reasons, as milking the prostate helps improve male sexual health.

[Image of male reproductive system]

Shop Prostate Massagers

Shop Prostate Massagers

Colt 5 Inch Power Male Anal Vibrator
Colt 5 Inch Power Male Anal Vibrator

Colt 5 Inch Power Male Anal Vibrator

(0)

$36.95 $22.00
Extra 10% off applied
Aneros Progasm Prostate Massager Classic
Aneros Progasm Prostate Massager Classic

Aneros Progasm Prostate Massager Classic

(0)

$67.95 $60.95
Extra 10% off applied
Sensuelle Homme Ace Rechargeable Prostate Dildo Massager
Sensuelle Homme Ace Rechargeable Prostate Dildo Massager

Sensuelle Homme Ace Rechargeable Prostate Dildo Massager

(10)

$97.95 $75.00
Dr Joel Kaplan 7.5 Inch Prostate Massager
Dr Joel Kaplan 7.5 Inch Prostate Massager

Dr Joel Kaplan 7.5 Inch Prostate Massager

(0)

$33.95 $27.00
Extra 10% off applied
View All Prostate Massagers

Anal Dildos

The anal dildos are dildos specifically designed for anal use, especially for men, and these are usually slimmer and have a broad base or a handle, and may have a realistic or non-realistic shape. The best ones are made from body-safe materials like silicone, glass, and metal, but there are plenty of other materials used to make anal dildos.

Shop Anal Dildos

Shop Dildos for Men

Blush Temptasia Twist Dildo Set for Men
Blush Temptasia Twist Dildo Set for Men

Temptasia Twist Dildo Set for Men

(9)

$60.95 $41.60
Blush B Yours Plus 5.5 Inch Hard n' Happy Dildo
Blush B Yours Plus 5.5 Inch Hard n' Happy Dildo

B Yours Plus 5.5 Inch Hard n' Happy Dildo

(6)

$20.95 $16.00
Extra 10% off applied
Color
King Cock 9 Inch Chubby Dildo
King Cock 9 Inch Chubby Dildo

King Cock 9 Inch Chubby Dildo

(14)

$72.95 From $64.00
Extra 10% off applied
Color
Dr. Skin 5.5 Inch Dildo with Suction Cup
Dr. Skin 5.5 Inch Dildo with Suction Cup

Dr. Skin 5.5 Inch Dildo with Suction Cup

(0)

$17.95 $12.79
Extra 10% off applied
View All Dildos for Men

Benefits of Using Anal Toys

Anal play is a very sensual form of sexual play, and you can experience more profound pleasure, which is not possible with other forms of sexual play. Because of the many nerve endings in the anus, when you stimulate these with the appropriate anal toy, you are in for a world of pleasure. Here are the key benefits of using anal toys:

  • Stronger orgasms – anal toys provide internal pressure that stimulates the genitalia. In women, using anal toys like butt plugs provide a feeling of fullness, adding pressure on the vagina and the anterior fornix and helping with stimulation of the G-spot. It also helps that the vaginal walls are stimulated from both sides, which leads to more powerful orgasms.
  • Prostate stimulation – in males, using anal toys is excellent as it stimulates the prostate, the walnut-sized gland that is about three inches on the front wall of the rectum. Utilizing a prostate massager, a male anal dildo, or a butt plug can really stimulate the P-spot and cause a whole-body orgasm that you can’t achieve with any other type of stimulation.
  • Power play – using anal toys is a common theme in BDSM plays, as these are very apt for power play exchanges. Using anal toys requires a great deal of trust between partners, making these suited for BDSM scenarios where discipline and power plays are needed.
  • Preparation for anal sex – using anal toys will train the anus for something more extensive, like a penis. Using an anal training kit will make the insertion of anal toys easier, which will prepare the muscles to be more comfortable and relaxed for anal sex.

The Bottom Line

We hope our guide on how to choose anal toys is helpful, and we’ve touched on all the basics about using and choosing anal toys. We have a lot more guides on various topics related to using and choosing various sex toys, so make sure you check out our blog. We invite you to browse our sex toy store, where we carry an impressive array of anal sex toys, dildos, vibrators, male toys, BDSM tools, and much more.

Learn More With Our Anal Sex Toy Guides:

How to Use Anal Toys?
How to Use Anal Trainers?
How to Use a Butt Plug?
How to Use an Inflatable Butt Plug?
How to Use A Prostate Massager?
How to Properly Stretch Your Anus?
How to Anal Douche?
How to Use Aneros Prostate Massagers?