50% off or More on Top Brands! Shop Now

Get extra 15% off with code: SPRING

Free Shipping on Orders $69+

Best Butt Plugs for Beginners: Ease into Anal Play

Best Butt Plugs for Beginners: Ease into Anal Play

Editorial Team |

Are you curious about anal play? The only way to find out if it’s the right choice for you is to test those backdoor waters. of course, there are toys specialized for this use: anal plugs for beginners are designed just for that purpose.

Small, easy to insert, and pleasurable at the same time, beginner butt plugs will take you where you haven’t gone before. To help you choose the right one, we put our team of curious testers to action in finding the best beginner anal plugs. We supplied them with a bunch of butt plugs, and their research has produced the following list of top butt plug picks for beginners.

Quick Overview of Our Top Pics

  1. Best Overall Choice: Luxe Beginner Silicone Butt Plug Kit
  2. Best Value Butt Plug: Fantasy For Her Designer Love Plug Set 
  3. Best for Beginners: Silicone Anal Starter Kit
  4. Best Silicone Butt Plug Set: Fantasy For Her - Her Little Gems Trainer Set
  5. Best Budget Butt Plug Set: First-Time Crystal Booty Kit
  6. Best Slim Vibrating Plug: Blush Luxe Wearable Vibra Slim Plug
  7. Best Remote Control Butt Plug: Femme Funn Plua Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control
  8. Best Jeweled Glass Butt Plug: Booty Sparks Pink Gem Glass Anal Plug
  9. Best Trainer Set: Mood Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set of 3
  10. Best Complete Anal Trainer Kit: Ultimate Butt Plug Training Kit

Deep Dive: Our Top Pics

Luxe Beginner Silicone Butt Plug Kit

Best Overall Choice

Our Rating: 4.9/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 4/5
Ease of Use: 5/5
Recommended For: Beginners

Why We Picked It

Not only does this pick give you excellent quality, but you’ll also receive three butt plugs that get progressively bigger. With butt plug trainers like these, you can gradually increase the stretch to experience the full extent of anal stimulation.

The butt plug starter kit is made of soft, flexible silicone. We also loved the ergonomic shapes and tapered tips – an ideal design for easy insertion. We’d like to mention the very small size of the first plug. It’s super tiny and non-threatening, even for absolute rookies.

Each of the plugs has a flared base for added safety. There’s also a suction cup on the bottom. During our tests, it worked well on all kinds of surfaces and held the plug in place throughout the session.

Who It's For

The kit is great for beginners and it may even appeal to some who have a bit more experience with anal play. Well-made and crafted from high-quality materials, it’s an excellent addition to any sex toy collection.

Specs

Dimensions 3.25” x 0.75”, 4.25” x 1”, 5.25” 1.25”
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Flexible
Suction Cup Base
Increasing Sizes
Unisex Design
Temperature Sensitive

Fantasy for Her Designer Love Plug Set

Best Value Butt Plug

Our Rating: 4.9/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 5/5
Ease of Use: 4/5
Recommended For: Beginners

Why We Picked It

This plug set features a different base design and we also like the little grooves running down the length of each probe. Designed to hold lube better, the grooves do keep things wet and slippery for longer periods of time.

As the name suggests, this is a kit for beginners consisting of two plugs. One measures an inch in width while the bigger one’s diameter is 1.25 inches. Both deliver a nice stretching sensation without being overwhelming.

We found the plugs easy to use because of the tapered tip design and the smooth silicone both are made of. The material also makes the plug waterproof and easy to clean thoroughly (just get into those grooves to remove any lube residue). Shower fun is also in the cards with this set for beginners.

Who It's For

With two sizes to choose from, the set has something to offer to both beginners and slightly more experienced players. The most dedicated anal sex enthusiasts should probably look for another option.

Specs

Dimensions 3" x 1", 3.5" x 1.25"
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Lube-Retaining Groovese
Contoured Base
Set of 2
Flexible
Temperature Sensitive

Silicone Anal Starter Kit

Best for Beginners

Our Rating: 4.7/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 4/5
Ease of Use: 5/5
Recommended For: Beginners

Why We Picked It

Out of all choices we tested, this is probably the most non-threatening kit for complete anal newbies. All three of the plugs are reasonably sized and they have a slender tip design for effortless insertion. The widest point isn’t too girthy and the smallest one is as petite as a finger. We felt the stretch but at no point did it get overwhelming.

The kit is made from smooth, flexible, and waterproof silicone. It is easy to clean – dunk it in soapy water or boil it for a few minutes to get the plugs sterilized.

Flared bases for added safety are available and the butt plugs are also equipped with suction cups. We tried the suction cup hold on tiles, glass, mirrors, marble, and other smooth surfaces – it performed so well each time.

Who It's For

Because of the slender design, this butt plug set is best suited to the needs of complete beginners. They’re also a good choice for casual anal players and those interested in gentle anal stimulation.

Specs

Dimensions 2.75" x 0.75", 3.75" x 1", 4.5" x 1.25"
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Suction Cup Base
Flexible
3 Increasing Sizes
Tapered Design

Fantasy for Her – Her Little Gems Trainer Set

Best Silicone Butt Plug Set

Our Rating: 4.9/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 5/5
Ease of Use: 4/5
Recommended For: Everyone

Why We Picked It

Some of us love a bit of bling-bling – it makes sex so much more visually exciting. We were eager to test these bejeweled butt plugs that are perfectly sized for beginners. Not only do they look exquisite, they also feel great.

The Fantasy for Her – Her Little Gems set consists of three silky smooth silicone plugs bragging faux gem bases. Each one delivers a bit of gentle stretching while the narrow stem makes them ideal for prolonged use.

While the plugs are designed for gentle play, we definitely felt their girth because of the specific design. They’re also hefty, meaning the arousing sensation will continue even when the plug is fully inserted.

Who It's For

While this butt plug trainer kit is mainly designed for the needs of beginners, it can be pleasurable for everyone. The plugs are beautiful and well-made, adding a wonderful visual element to sexual experiences.

Specs

Dimensions 2.8" x 1.1", 3.2" x 1.4", 3.8" x 1.7"
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Three Increasing Sizes
Body-Safe Surface
Behinner-Friendly Size
Sparkling Faux Gem
Spade Shape for Comfort

First-Time Crystal Booty Kit

Best Budget Butt Plug Set

Our Rating: 4.7/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 4/5
Ease of Use: 4/5
Recommended For: Everyone

Why We Picked It

The fabulous butt plug starter kit has a name to remember and a design to get naughty with. Our testers can't figure out which color they like more – both the pink and the blue varieties look expensive and sophisticated.

These plugs have a slightly thicker stem and they deliver a bit of anal training even when fully inserted. We used them as added stimulation during vaginal sex and they effortlessly intensified all sensations.

All three plugs in the kit are made from smooth and flexible silicone that’s very beginner-friendly. Crystal decorations on the base make the plugs beautiful to look at and they bejewel the booty when fully inserted for the perfect visual a lover’s going to appreciate.

Who It's For

Manageable in size, the butt plugs are great for beginners and casual players. The thicker stems, however, also make them an arousing pick for more experienced anal practitioners.

Specs

Dimensions 2" x 0.5", 2.5" x 0.75", 3.5" x 1"
Material Silicone, Acrylic
Features Waterproof
Semi-Flexible
Three Sizes
Streamlined Design
Flared Base
Sparkling Gem

Blush Luxe Wearable Vibra Slim Plug

Best Slim Vibrating Plug

Our Rating: 4.8/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 5/5
Ease of Use: 4/5
Recommended For: Everyone

Why We Picked It

There’s something really interesting about the Blush Luxe Wearable Vibra Slim Plugs. The movements of the body when the plug’s inside activate an internal vibrating mechanism that doesn’t need batteries to run. We tried it and the sensation is distinctive – stimulating without being too strong. It’s a gentle pleasurable presence that makes the plug so exciting to have inside.

The design is slightly different from what other beginner butt plugs look like. This one has a rounded head that’s still tapered enough for easy insertion. It delivers a sense of fullness for a long-lasting period.

An anchor-like base makes the plug safe while also increasing comfort, even if you have the toy inside for hours at a time.

Who It's For

The plug is petite enough to meet the needs of inexperienced users. At the same time, the gentle body-powered vibrations add an element of excitement that will bring experienced users some enjoyment.

Specs

Dimensions 3.5" x 1", 4" x 1."
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Flexible
Manual Vibrations
Flared Base
2 Size Options

Femme Funn Plua Vibrating Butt Plug

Best Remote Control Butt Plug

Our Rating: 4.7/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 4/5
Ease of Use: 5/5
Recommended For: Everyone

Why We Picked It

Did you think we’ve forgotten everyone who needs some extra stimulation? Our testers tried the Femme Funn Plua and they all enjoyed its intensity. The butt plug has a beginner-friendly design that’s simply enhanced by the powerful vibrations.

The first thing we noticed about this little guy is its smoothness. The silicone coating feels expensive and seamless. It also protects the motor inside, making the butt plug completely waterproof.

An intuitive wireless remote fits right in the palm of the hand. With just two buttons, it’s very easy to operate even when you’re getting close to O town.

A final thing worth mentioning is the size and shape of the Plua. It is anatomically designed to deliver a sense of fullness and some gentle stretching bound to get those anal nerve endings singing with pleasure.

Who It's For

Femme Funn Plua is a beginner-friendly butt plug. The dimensions are manageable and great for easy insertion. At the same time, the 10 vibration settings increase variety and deliver the intensity more experienced users may crave.

Specs

Dimensions 4.4" x 1.4"
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Vibrating
USB Rechargeable
Streamlined Design
10 Vibrating Patterns
Wireless Remote Control

Booty Sparks Pink Gem Glass Anal Plug

Best Jeweled Glass Butt Plug

Our Rating: 4.7/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 5/5
Ease of Use: 3.5/5
Recommended For: Everyone

Why We Picked It

Glass is a whole different ball game when it comes to anal stuff. The rigidity and the weight of a glass plug make it more stimulating but it can also be a bit more challenging for newbies. That’s why we’ve chosen the Booty Sparks Pin Gem plug for inclusion in our list.

The shape, size, and design make it easy to use, regardless of the rigidity. The plug has a nicely tapered tip and the smoothness of glass adds to the ease of insertion.

The one thing we were really eager to experiment with is temperature play. Glass can be warmed or cooled down to add another dimension to erotic stimulation. Most of us enjoy temperature play a lot, as it increases sensitivity in sensitive areas and makes erogenous zones tingle with excitement.

Who It's For

The shape and size of this plug are great for beginners. Since it’s made of glass, however, it will probably appeal to more experienced players. The heft and rigidity of the glass turn the plug into an amazing stimulation toy for prolonged use.

Specs

Dimensions 2.8" x 1", 3.3" x 1.3", 3.9" x 1.6"
Material Glass
Features Waterproof
Temperature Sensitive
Tapered Tip
Three Sizes to Select From
Compatible with All Lubes
Sparkling Gem Base

Mood Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set of 3

Best Trainer Set

Our Rating: 4.7/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 4/5
Ease of Use: 5/5
Recommended For: Everyone

Why We Picked It

This set of anal plugs for beginners is great for erotic stimulation and for extensive anal training. The plugs feature our favorite kind of base – a narrow anchor that sits comfortably outside the body and doesn’t cause any irritation.

Narrow stems and ergonomic designs facilitate insertion and keep the plugs in place for as long as you need them to be there.

All three butt plug trainers are crafted from seamless, smooth silicone. We found the material very luxurious and it also holds lube nicely. The construction is fully waterproof, making the plugs very easy to clean (they can even be boiled if you’d like to do some thorough sterilization).

Who It's For

This butt plug starter kit has toys ranging in width from 0.75 to 1.25 inches. This variety means everyone will find something to enjoy in the set. It’s a quality pick for newbies and it will also excite more experienced players.

Specs

Dimensions 3.25" x 0.75", 4" x 1", 5" x 1.25"
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Set of Three Sizes
Flared T-Style Base
Unisex Design
Delicate Taper
Narrow Neck

Ultimate Butt Plug Training Kit

Best Complete Anal Trainer Kit

Our Rating: 4.6/5
Quality: 5/5
Design: 4/5
Ease of Use: 4/5
Recommended For: Everyone

Why We Picked It

Here’s a great product for beginners because it includes everything needed for a satisfying anal session.

Our tests confirmed the ease of using the three butt plugs that progressively get bigger. With slightly thicker stems than other beginner plugs, these sleek guys will keep you slightly stretched even when they’re fully inside.

The easy-squeeze anal douche bulb is intuitive and effortless. If you like to get things very clean before a booty session, you’ll need this one. Its capacity is large enough to allow for a thorough rinse bound to give you confidence and peace of mind.

All three plugs in the kit are made from hypoallergenic, waterproof silicone. They are very easy to clean and you can even boil them to sterilize the material every once in a while.

Who It's For

We feel the size and shape of these butt plugs make them great for beginners, intermediate and casual users. More experienced anal players may want to look for girthier choices out there.

Specs

Dimensions 4" x 1", 4.25" x 1.25", 5" x 1.5"
Material Silicone
Features Waterproof
Douche Bulb Included
Unisex Design
Tapered Tip
Suction Cup Base

Why Trust Our Reviews?

HotCherry’s editorial team includes sex experts, including sexologists, sexual health writers, product testers, and researchers. Having an editorial team lets us get a holistic view of the products in each category and choose the best products from top brands. We also have first-hand access to customer reviews on our website and consult with our customer service team to identify potential issues and defects of the products in our lists after long-term use.

Our selection method is meticulous: our experts hand-pick the best products to feature in each guide based on customer reviews, popularity, brand reputation, product features, and customer satisfaction post-purchase. Then, the editorial team personally tests and reviews every product, looking for all the traits that make a product unique and worthy of being featured in our best products lists. Then, we summarize the findings and bring detailed buying guides that are helpful for you.

When reviewing a product, our experts pay attention to the material, shape, size, and features with a keen eye and point out potential issues of every product. We also call out what the product feels like based on our reviewers’ personal experiences, which helps us bring you valuable insight.

Shop All Butt Plugs

Three Column Layout

Learn About our Favorite Sex Toys

Previous Next